Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Nestle CEO says Baby Milk Affair "Storm in Teacup"
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

SWITZERLAND: November 24, 2005


ZURICH - Nestle dismissed the recall of millions of litres of baby milk in Europe as a "storm in a teacup" on Wednesday as the European Commission said the tainted product was unlikely to pose a threat to public health.


Chief Executive and Chairman Peter Brabeck blamed Italian politics and the packaging industry for the controversy over the recalled baby products, which contained traces of ink from their Tetra Pak cartons.

"It's nothing. It's a storm in a teacup," Brabeck told journalists in Zurich. "There is no risk to safety."

"This has more to do with politics than anything else," he added.

Italy's Agriculture Minister Gianni Alemanno called Brabeck's comments "serious and disconcerting" and urged investigators to get to the bottom of the incident.

"We trust that the magistrates will shed light on this affair which we continue to believe was unacceptable," he said.

On Tuesday, Italian police said they seized 30 million litres of Nestle liquid baby milk from supermarket shelves and from depots after it showed traces of ink.

Swiss-based Nestle announced it recalled products in Italy, Spain, Portugal and France because of the problem.

Nestle said the amount of liquid baby food involved was 2 million litres, not 30 million as stated by Italian police.

"Their number is totally absurd. The maximum amount in circulation at any given time is 1.8 to 1.9 million litres," said chief spokesman Francois-Xavier Perroud.

Italian Health Minister Francesco Storace threatened to sue Brabeck over comments he had made that Nestle had reached an agreement with his ministry over the handling of the products.

"We learn with dismay that the CEO of Nestle Peter Brabeck, in a statement transmitted by the Reuters agency, said that Nestle had already agreed in July with the European Union and Italy's Ministry of Health to let the products expire and to change the production process for the cartons.

"These statements are not only completely false, but overturn the real course of events. In fact it was the Italian health ministry which brought the affair to light," he said in a statement.


NO TOXIC THREAT

Analysis of the milk by the EU's Food Safety Agency determined that the chemical substance isopropylthioxanthone (ITX) should not pose a toxic threat in the levels detected, a spokesman for the European Commission told journalists.

"On the basis of the limited data available, the presence of ITX in food could be considered undesirable. However, it is not likely to present an immediate health risk at the levels reported," spokesman Philip Tod said.

Tetra Pak, the company that makes the cartons, defended its actions.

"We continue to believe that the packages are safe and we believe we have taken appropriate measures, not only to keep everybody informed but also in taking precautionary action," said spokeswoman Patricia O'Hayer.

Analysts welcomed Brabeck's efforts to limit fallout but said it could still dent the company's image.

In May, Nestle pulled milk powder from shelves in China after it exceeded limits on iodine content. As a result, demand for Nestle products across China fell, Nestle said in July.

The event also recalls a boycott of Nestle products in the late 1970s and early 1980s by activists protesting against its marketing of infant formula in developing countries.

"I am glad that Brabeck is coming out and talking about the infant liquid formula problem," said analyst Jon Cox at Kepler Equities in a research note.

"Nestle is taking a proactive approach to the problem in an attempt to limit further damage -- there is always the risk it spills over into other Nestle brands in the countries affected, particularly Italy."

Italy is the company's fifth-biggest market, with annual sales of 4.4 billion francs ($3.34 billion), Cox said.

The cost to the company of pulling the products off shelves would be 2 million to 2.5 million euros ($2.34 million-$2.93 million), an "absolutely negligible" amount, Brabeck said.

Nestle's shares ended Wednesday trading little changed at 396 francs.

(Additional reporting by Douwe Miedema and Isabel Stra


Story by Thomas Atkins


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
24 NOV 2005
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
FEATURE - Islands Battle Rising Seas for Survival

BELGIUM:
Denmark may Compensate for GMO Contamination - EU

BELGIUM:
Merkel Praises EU Chemicals Compromise

BELGIUM:
Britain Beats Brussels in CO2 Emissions Court Case

CANADA:
Environment Hurt by Canada's Oil Sands Boom - Report

CHINA:
China Reports Second Death from Bird Flu

CHINA:
Polluted River Water Heads towards Chinese City

ITALY:
Italy Health Minister says to Sue Nestle Chief

KENYA:
UN says Sonar Threatens Dolphin and Whale Survival

SOUTH KOREA:
FEATURE - South Korean Cloning Pioneer Battles Ethics Charges

SWITZERLAND:
Nestle CEO says Baby Milk Affair "Storm in Teacup"

UK:
Drift to Nuclear Power Angers UK Environmentalists

UK:
Chronic Noise Linked to Raised Risk of Heart Attack

USA:
Patchwork US Greenhouse Gas Market Grows Slowly



previous day
today's news
next day


This site developed by Frontline, and managed by Planet Ark using RPM-NT.

Site designed by Jon Dee @ Planet Ark.

Radiant